Skip to Main Content

Selecting teaching resources: a guide: Select and evaluate

Ethical selection and use of teaching resources

 Providing credible, rigorously evaluated resources

Resource Selection Criteria

Selecting teaching resources

Consider Quality and Practical characteristics of your selected resources alongside pedagogic and policy fit. 

Quality Considerations

Use the BASIC method to help in the evaluation process.

B - Broad

Does the content include several perspectives, show how meaning is negotiated and established, provide the historical angle, explore dissenting views and even include those from outside the discipline?

A - Authoritative

Is the content authoritative? Have you determined the validity of the resource, taken into account new perspectives and changes in thought, and questioned the origin and context of the created information?

Acknowledge that biases arising from positions of privilege can arise from accepted sources of authority. Apply this understanding to all formats you select, including online videos and images.

S - at Standard

Is the content at the appropriate AQF level for your course? Does it meet the benchmarks of a School policy or the standards of industry, sector or professional regulatory bodies?

Do your search strategies for teaching content retrieve the results to meet the information needs of your students? Will your students be able to achieve the learning outcomes of the AQF level by interacting with material you have selected?

I - Inclusive & Equitable

Is the content you select culturally appropriate, sensitive and inclusive of indigenous peoples? Does your selection of material encourage Indigenous Knowledges? Has the content been evaluated for authenticity and accuracy with input from Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples?

Know your student cohort. Are your selected resources appropriate for international, rural and low socio-economic status students?

For example:

  • is there a digital version that all students can access regardless of mode of learning?
  • does your content reflect international perspectives, or present local issues within global contexts?
C - Current

Are your resources current, or, in the case of set textbooks, is a more recent edition available? Perhaps you have a range of authoritative materials that span recent decades.

Whilst in some disciplines older works may be most authoritative, recent works should be presented to students for them to explore emergent schools of thought and new discoveries. New research must be acknowledged in the scholarly conversation, encouraging further contributions to research in the discipline.

 

Practical Considerations

Is the format accessible – in print or electronic version? 

Is the resource legitimate, legal to use? 

Consider equity of access for all students. What is the cost for students?  

  • Textbooks: How much is the print copy? Is there an e-version of the textbook for individuals to purchase? 
  • Does the source require special equipment to access? 
  • Would an Open Educational Resource (OER) be an appropriate alternative? 

Is a suitable licence available? 

  • can the Library purchase a multi-user licence for an ebook? Is it fair for your students to set an open book exam if there are only 3 simultaneous users per licence? 
  • Is the resource only available to individual subscribers (for example, most online newspapers)?
  • is there an institutional licence available to purchase for the resource? 

Will the resource be available to students in China or other teaching locations? 

References

Arkoudis, S. (n.d.). Teaching international students: Strategies to enhance learning. https://msd.unimelb.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0007/3064372/ArkoudisS-Teaching-International-ST.pdf

Association of College and Research Libraries. (2015). Framework for information literacy for higher education. American Library Association. http://www.ala.org/acrl/standards/ilframework

Centre for Learning Innovation and Professional Practice (CLIPP). (2019). BOLD learning and teaching practices. https://federation.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/425373/BOLD_LT_PRACTICES_July2019_Print.pdf

International Center for Academic Integrity. (2021). The fundamental values of academic integrity. https://academicintegrity.org/images/pdfs/20019_ICAI-Fundamental-Values_R12.pdf

Queensland Studies Authority. (2007). Selecting and evaluating resources (Indigenous Perspectives Guidelines, Issue G008). https://www.qcaa.qld.edu.au/downloads/approach2/indigenous_g008_0712.pdf

Tertiary Education Quality and Standards Agency. (2019). Guidance Note: Academic Integrity. https://www.teqsa.gov.au/latest-news/publications/guidance-note-academic-integrity

Consider teaching policy & pedagogic fit

Consider Industry standards

Accreditation requirements by any relevant registering bodies is an essential component of curriculum resource choice for some industries.

Contact us

Contact your Liaison Librarian for assistance with selecting resources.

Contact Details:  Research and Learning Services Team